The Silent Squeeze: 8 Pressures Behind Today’s Freight Rate Collapse
📊 Subscribe to the Ship Universe Weekly Newsletter
Freight rates are tumbling again, leaving shipowners, brokers, and cargo shippers asking the same question: why now? The easy answer is “demand is weak,” but the reality is more complicated. Global utilization numbers show cargo is still moving, yet rates are under relentless pressure. The truth is that multiple forces, some structural, others cyclical, are converging to push prices down.
From a flood of new tonnage to shifting trade policies, falling bunker prices, and the quiet pressure of financial markets, freight rates are caught in what many insiders are calling a “silent squeeze.” Understanding these pressures isn’t just an academic exercise, it’s critical for shipowners planning fleet strategies, financiers assessing risk, and shippers trying to lock in contracts at the right time.
Below, we break down the eight forces most responsible for today’s falling freight rates and what they really mean for the industry.
1️⃣ Overcapacity From Newbuilds
➕ Expand details
🚢 What’s happening
Carriers placed large orders during the pandemic super-cycle. These vessels, many of them larger and more efficient, are entering service at a time of softer demand. Even with blank sailings and slow steaming, the sheer volume of capacity has intensified price competition across major trade lanes.
📉 Why it pushes rates down
- Too many slots: More available TEU capacity than cargo growth can absorb.
- Utilization optics: High utilization can still coincide with weak pricing when absolute capacity is excessive.
- Competitive behavior: To keep ships moving, lines often accept lower-yield cargo.
🔎 Signals to watch
- Monthly delivered TEU vs. scrapped/laid-up TEU (net capacity change).
- Frequency of blank sailings and service withdrawals.
- Contract vs. spot rate spreads; widening gaps signal oversupply stress.
👥 Implications by stakeholder
- Shipowners: Charter renewals face pressure; evaluate older tonnage for scrapping or sale.
- Shippers: Greater bargaining power; use flexible contracts to benefit from lower spot prices.
- Financiers: Rising risk exposure; stress-test assumptions under prolonged low-rate conditions.
📊 Data points to track
- World Container Index (WCI) levels and year-on-year trends.
- Freightos Baltic Index (FBX) snapshots on key lanes.
- Orderbook-to-fleet ratio and demolition rates.
Note: Overcapacity often builds quietly, then suddenly exerts heavy pressure when new deliveries cluster within a short window.
2️⃣ Softening Global Demand
➕ Expand details
🚢 What’s happening
Inflation, higher borrowing costs, and muted retail sales have cooled global imports. Retailers in North America and Europe still hold excess inventory from earlier buying cycles, delaying fresh orders. At the same time, manufacturing output in several regions has slowed, dampening containerized trade.
📉 Why it pushes rates down
- Lower import appetite: Fewer shipments from Asia into the West.
- Inventory overhang: Warehouses remain stocked, so replenishment is postponed.
- Sluggish production: Less cross-border demand for inputs and finished goods.
🔎 Signals to watch
- Global manufacturing PMI trends.
- Retail inventory-to-sales ratios in the U.S. and Europe.
- Trade volumes on Asia–U.S. and Asia–Europe routes.
👥 Implications by stakeholder
- Shipowners: Tougher competition to secure bookings on key trade lanes.
- Shippers: More leverage in contract negotiations, especially long-term deals.
- Financiers: Lower visibility on earnings; exposure to cyclical downturn risk rises.
📊 Data points to track
- World Container Index (WCI) and Freightos Baltic Index (FBX) shifts.
- Import/export volumes published by WTO, IMF, and national customs agencies.
- Earnings reports from large global retailers (inventory guidance).
Note: Demand softening doesn’t crash rates by itself, but in combination with oversupply its impact grows sharply.
3️⃣ Carrier Rate Wars
➕ Expand details
🚢 What’s happening
With too many ships chasing too little cargo, carriers often turn to aggressive pricing. History shows that when utilization falls, lines undercut each other to avoid losing volume. This dynamic has resurfaced in 2025, echoing the 2016 rate war that ended with Hanjin’s collapse.
📉 Why it pushes rates down
- Market share battles: Carriers discount heavily to hold onto contracts.
- Short-term survival: Better to fill ships cheaply than sail half-empty.
- Reinforced spiral: One carrier’s cut pressures rivals to follow suit.
🔎 Signals to watch
- Spot rates dropping faster than demand metrics suggest.
- Blank sailings announced but offset by discounted slots.
- Reports of undercutting in key Asia–U.S. and Asia–Europe tenders.
👥 Implications by stakeholder
- Shipowners: Charter renewals risk falling below breakeven levels.
- Shippers: Opportunities to lock in rock-bottom rates, though service reliability may suffer.
- Financiers: Higher default risk for weaker carriers during prolonged price wars.
📊 Data points to track
- Contract vs. spot price spreads widening quickly.
- Quarterly results from major carriers showing declining revenue per TEU.
- Industry consolidation activity or alliance reshuffling.
Note: Rate wars rarely last forever, but they can accelerate losses and push weaker carriers out of the market.
4️⃣ Tariff & Trade Policy Volatility
➕ Expand details
🚢 What’s happening
Governments are increasingly using tariffs and trade restrictions as political tools. The result is a cycle of “panic bookings” ahead of tariff deadlines, followed by quieter periods when shippers pause or reroute cargo. These swings make it harder for carriers to balance capacity and pricing.
📉 Why it pushes rates down
- Artificial surges: Temporary demand spikes inflate rates briefly, but disappear quickly.
- Aftershock lulls: Once tariffs are in place, shipments often slow, weakening rates.
- Rerouted cargo: Diversions can bypass traditional hubs, leaving extra slots on key lanes.
🔎 Signals to watch
- Announcements of new tariffs or trade agreements.
- Booking rushes ahead of deadline dates followed by sharp declines.
- Shifts in customs data showing rerouted or reduced flows.
👥 Implications by stakeholder
- Shipowners: Unpredictable swings make capacity planning difficult.
- Shippers: Need flexible contracts to adapt to sudden cost shifts.
- Financiers: Greater uncertainty around revenue forecasting for carriers exposed to tariff-sensitive routes.
📊 Data points to track
- U.S.–China and EU–Asia tariff announcements and timelines.
- Freight rate spikes tied to political events.
- Trade lane volume changes in customs and port data.
Note: Tariff shocks rarely drive long-term pricing, but their volatility disrupts stability and can accelerate downward cycles.
5️⃣ Financial Market Pressure
➕ Expand details
🚢 What’s happening
Listed carriers must answer to shareholders, while charter-heavy operators face fixed lease obligations. Even when market conditions are weak, the need to show revenue leads companies to prioritize filling ships over protecting margins. This financial pressure often drives rates lower than supply-demand dynamics alone would dictate.
📉 Why it pushes rates down
- Cash flow first: Better to earn less per TEU than leave capacity idle.
- Debt obligations: Carriers with heavy debt loads are compelled to move volume at almost any price.
- Market expectations: Public carriers feel pressure to show steady utilization and revenue.
🔎 Signals to watch
- Quarterly earnings showing revenue per TEU dropping while volume holds steady.
- Charter rate benchmarks vs. spot market divergence.
- Debt-to-equity ratios and refinancing activity among major carriers.
👥 Implications by stakeholder
- Shipowners: Pressure to accept lower charters; weaker players risk distress sales.
- Shippers: More bargaining power, though service reliability may vary as carriers chase cash flow.
- Financiers: Increased credit risk exposure, especially to operators reliant on short-term financing.
📊 Data points to track
- Carrier earnings releases (average revenue per TEU).
- Debt refinancing announcements and bond yields in shipping.
- Charter market trends compared with spot freight rates.
Note: Financial pressure doesn’t create oversupply, but it magnifies its impact by pushing carriers to chase revenue at any cost.
6️⃣ Geopolitical Disruptions
➕ Expand details
🚢 What’s happening
Red Sea security risks, Panama Canal draft restrictions, and political instability in key regions have forced carriers to reroute vessels. These detours increase transit times and costs, but have not removed enough tonnage from circulation to offset the broader oversupply issue.
📉 Why it pushes rates down
- Added costs: Rerouting raises expenses but doesn’t guarantee higher rates.
- Capacity absorption overstated: Extra days at sea slow vessels, but fleets remain oversupplied.
- Shipper resistance: Customers push back on surcharges, limiting carriers’ ability to pass on costs.
🔎 Signals to watch
- Security advisories in the Red Sea and Gulf of Aden.
- Panama Canal daily transit statistics and draft restrictions.
- Insurance premium adjustments for high-risk routes.
👥 Implications by stakeholder
- Shipowners: Higher operating costs and insurance premiums.
- Shippers: Longer transit times and potential rerouting surcharges.
- Financiers: Increased risk exposure on assets transiting volatile regions.
📊 Data points to track
- Canal authority updates (Panama and Suez).
- Global maritime insurance rate changes.
- Fleet reallocation patterns during conflicts.
Note: Geopolitical disruptions can shake the market, but without a structural reduction in tonnage their long-term impact on rates remains limited.
7️⃣ Seasonality & Inventory Cycles
➕ Expand details
🚢 What’s happening
Retailers in key markets entered 2025 still carrying higher-than-usual stock levels, dampening replenishment cycles. At the same time, seasonal surges like back-to-school and holiday imports have been softer compared with historical averages. The result is a flatter demand curve that offers carriers less relief from year-round oversupply.
📉 Why it pushes rates down
- Muted peaks: Traditional surges in Q3–Q4 fail to materialize at historic strength.
- Inventory overhang: Warehouses stocked with excess goods delay new orders.
- Weaker seasonality: Predictable rate bumps no longer offset troughs, keeping averages lower.
🔎 Signals to watch
- Retail inventory-to-sales ratios in North America and Europe.
- Holiday season and Lunar New Year booking trends.
- Port throughput statistics during traditional peak months.
👥 Implications by stakeholder
- Shipowners: Reliance on seasonal peaks to offset weak quarters is less reliable.
- Shippers: More bargaining power during periods that once favored carriers.
- Financiers: Greater volatility in revenue expectations when peaks underperform.
📊 Data points to track
- Monthly port throughput figures on major trade lanes.
- Seasonal shipping demand indices.
- Retail earnings guidance tied to holiday and seasonal cycles.
Note: Weak seasonality by itself doesn’t cause sharp declines, but it removes the relief valves that normally stabilize rates during the year.
8️⃣ Fuel Price Trends
➕ Expand details
🚢 What’s happening
Fluctuations in crude and refined products ripple into VLSFO, HSFO, and MGO prices. Carriers hedge selectively, but many still feel spot fuel moves. When fuel trends down, cost relief can translate into sharper pricing to win bookings, especially on lanes with abundant capacity.
📉 Why it pushes rates down
- Lower breakevens: Reduced voyage costs give carriers room to discount.
- Competitive pass-through: Lines cut all-in rates to defend utilization.
- Surcharge dynamics: BAF adjustments lag, so effective end-prices can dip faster than formulas imply.
🔎 Signals to watch
- Monthly VLSFO/HSFO/MGO price curves and their spreads.
- BAF (bunker adjustment factor) updates in carrier contracts.
- Crude benchmarks (Brent/WTI) and refinery margin trends.
👥 Implications by stakeholder
- Shipowners: Margin relief when fuel dips, but pricing pressure can offset gains.
- Shippers: Opportunity to negotiate lower all-in rates as BAFs reset.
- Financiers: Sensitivity of earnings to bunker swings; monitor hedging policies.
📊 Data points to track
- Global bunker indices and regional port fuel quotes.
- Carrier surcharge circulars and frequency of BAF changes.
- Correlation between bunker trends and spot rate movements on key lanes.
Note: Fuel moves influence margins first and freight rates second—most visible when capacity is abundant and price competition is intense.
Freight rates don’t fall for just one reason. They’re caught in the crossfire of structural forces like overcapacity, cyclical trends such as demand softness, and behavioral responses from carriers under financial strain. Together, these create the “silent squeeze” shaping today’s market. To bring it all into focus, here’s a side-by-side view of how each factor influences the current environment.
We welcome your feedback, suggestions, corrections, and ideas for enhancements. Please click here to get in touch.
